User:Moweez/Editing/Roads View history

(→‎Road Naming: combined info from various sources on naming)
(first guideline on Street and city naming)
Line 12: Line 12:
**abbreviations
**abbreviations
*atrributes/properties
*atrributes/properties
*locking standard (https://wiki.waze.com/wiki/MMR_India#Road_Segment_Locks )
*KISS
*KISS
*Double lane or single lane / Divide or undivide
*Double lane or single lane / Divide or undivide
Line 25: Line 24:
* Main interconnecting roads with fast traffic should ar least be MH (major Highway)
* Main interconnecting roads with fast traffic should ar least be MH (major Highway)
Please read the [[India_Quickstart#Road_type|Quickstart guide to road types]] before changing the type.
Please read the [[India_Quickstart#Road_type|Quickstart guide to road types]] before changing the type.
The following convention should be followed where possible, although it is acknowledged that you may need to deviate from it in some circumstances.
{| class="wikitable unsortable" style="background:white; font-size:80%; margin: 1em auto 1em auto" border="1"
|-
! Waze Road Type
! India Road Types (to be checked/updated)
! [[Editing/Roads#Locking_Standard|Lock Level]]
|-
| {{Freeway}}
|
*National Highways that are referenced in the map below (move map from [[India_Quickstart#Road_type|Road types in Quick Start]]) <!--NEED TO CHANGE TO ROAD TYPES PARAGRAPH/PAGE-->
*Highways appointed by local champs to enable long routes
| 5
|-
| {{Major Highway}}
|
*Other National Highways (exception: inner roads within Indian Metro Cities)
*Ring Roads around large cities
| 4
|-
| {{Minor Highway}}
|
*All State Highways
*Arterial Roads, and inner highway roads within Indian Metro Cities
*Roads used for through-going traffic or for longer distances connecting towns or villages
| 3
|-
| {{Primary Street}}
| Busy Roads within Cities, and/or Feeder Roads to Arterial Roads
| 2
|-
| {{Street}}
| Residential Roads
| Automatic (1)
|-
| {{PLR}}
| Used for Petrol Stations, Car Parks
| Automatic (1)
|}


Always make sure a road is at least connected to a same level of road type or higher. Thus, Waze should be able to route from primary to primary (or higher), from minor to minor (or higher), from major to major (or higher), and from Freeway to Freeway. Another way of explaining this, is that you should be able to continuously drive on the same or higher type of segments for the routing engine to use that road type in the calculations.
Always make sure a road is at least connected to a same level of road type or higher. Thus, Waze should be able to route from primary to primary (or higher), from minor to minor (or higher), from major to major (or higher), and from Freeway to Freeway. Another way of explaining this, is that you should be able to continuously drive on the same or higher type of segments for the routing engine to use that road type in the calculations.


This means we need to sometimes make small roads mH, for the possibility of calculating long distance routing. Please discuss with the hosts/mentors if anything is unclear.  
This means we need to sometimes make small roads mH, for the possibility of calculating long distance routing. Please discuss with the hosts/mentors if anything is unclear.  
As for road types, please use the [[India_Quickstart#Road_type|table in the quickstart page]] with the map as follows: <!--WE SHOULD NOT REFER TO THE QUICK START GUIDE, AS THIS SHOULD BE THE ELABORATE PAGE WITH ALL THE EXPLANATION-->
Freeway: National Highways that are referenced in the map
Major Highway (MH): National Highways that aren’t seen in the map
Minor Highway (mH): All State Highways and Arterial Roads within Indian Metro Cities


=Road Naming=
=Road Naming=
The naming of the roads in India is quite a challenge. Many roads don't have a name or are referred to as the "Road from A to B". And if there are specific names, they are often duplicates, even withing one city.
The naming of the roads in India is quite a challenge. Many roads don't have a name or are referred to as the "Road from A to B". And if there are specific names, they are often duplicates, even withing one city.


Line 43: Line 75:
*visibility/readability in the app
*visibility/readability in the app
*continuous routing
*continuous routing
*distinguishing
*distinguishing unique addresses
 
We want Waze to guide us to the correct location. Each location needs to have a unique address. In India, there are 6 or 7 address fields to reach that. We only have 4 fields in WME to define this unique address. Two of them are fixed (Country and State). The other two (Street and City) will be used to define unique addresses.
(picture of WME address field with and without added subdivision)
 
If there are cities with the same name within a State, a street has a name that exist over a very long stretch, or has duplicates within the city, we use the district or the sub-district to make the address unique. See Street naming and City naming for more information.


Please follow the guidelines below:
If you are looking for a proper naming, and you need to add the district or sub-district, look at this page for more information on the [[States|administrative division of India]].


===Streetnames===
===Street naming===
Official streetnames always go in the Primary name field. If a street has two or more names, we choose the shortest as the Primary name, and the other one goes in alternate name.
Official streetnames always go in the Primary name field.  


'''naming of highways''' (link to road types?):
*If a street has two or more names, we choose the shortest as the Primary name, and the other one goes in alternate name.
*only when a road has a specific name in urban areas that is used in adresses, it can be in the primary name  
*If one or more streets in an area have no names, we can use the district or sub-district in the streetname to distinguish the area (see XX)
*otherwise, the main road number will be in primary
*If there are multiple streets with the same name in the same city, we use the district or sub-district in the city name to distinguish them. (see XX)
*'''naming of highways''' (link to road types?):
**only when a road has a specific name in urban areas that is used in adresses, it can be in the primary name  
**otherwise, the main road number* will be in primary
::all numbers are written as NH-XX, SH-XX, AH-XX and the like
::all numbers are written as NH-XX, SH-XX, AH-XX and the like
*all other necessary numbers go in alternate name
**all other necessary numbers go in alternate name
*names indicating destinations go in alternate name (e.g., Mumbai Pune Highway)
**names indicating destinations go in alternate name (e.g., Mumbai Pune Highway)


Note on highway numbers:
Note on highway numbers:
*we use the numbers as it is on the map
*we use the numbers as they are on the map
*we only use the new numbers if it is requested via UR. We then put the old number as alternate name
*we only use the new road numbers if it is requested via UR. We then put the old number as alternate name
 
===City naming===
The City field should be used to specify the city, town or village for all the streets within it. Rural roads that are in-between towns should be left without a city name.


City attribution (READ the next paragraph on City naming too!):
'''Where possible, the simplest unique name should be used'''.
 
For very large cities with suburbs, then the suburb should become the name of the town with the city name as the suffix (add example). This is particularly important for generating useful traffic reports, especially when there are long arterial or ring roads that go through several parts of the city.
 
====City Smudges====
The editor will display the error message "The highlighted road is too far from the city it was added to" when attempting to add a duplicate name. This is to prevent ''smudges'' and means that a different name will need to be chosen for that town or village.
 
For problems with smudged cities, we are currently gathering [[MapRaid_troubleshooting#Smudged_cities_.2F_saving_errors|several solutions and workarounds]].
 
In case of multiple cities/towns with the same name in one area, we use district or sub-district to distinguish them (see XX).
 
In short:
*only in urban areas (urban=where people live in municipalities)
*only in urban areas (urban=where people live in municipalities)
*only when you are absolutely sure
*use the simplest unique name
*only when you are absolutely sure of the name
*otherwise, check the _None_ box
*otherwise, check the _None_ box


===City names===
===advanced road naming ===
We want Waze to guide us to the correct location. Each location needs to have a unique address. In India, there are 6 or 7 address fields to reach that. We only have 4 fields in WME to define this unique adress.
In case of multiple cities/towns or streetnames with the same name in one area, we use district or sub-district to distinguish them.
(picture of WME address field with and without added subdivision)
 
to be elaborated


Therefore, if a street has a name that exist over a very long stretch, or has duplicates within the city, we use the sub-district to make the address unique. The sub-district will be added in parentheses after the city name in the city field, BUT ONLY IN ALTERNATE NAME. Never in primary name. See the picture for an example.
=Locking Standard=
As the map of India still needs a lot of improvement, we don't want to lock too much that could block starting editors. However, to ensure routing, especially over larger distances, we do use locks for some roads according to the table below. Roads that need more protection because of special situations (construction, complicated design, frequent editing errors) may be locked higher. '''Make sure to thoroughly check the routing in the live map, before you lock the roads.'''


If you are looking for a proper naming, and you need to add the sub-district, the table shows how the sub-districts are refered to in the various states. If the state has a link, you will find more state specific info in that link:
If you need to edit a road above your lock level, [https://www.waze.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=561 ask an unlock] or ask a higher level editor in one of the [[Community#Communication|communication platforms]] to do the edit for you.


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|-
|-
! State/Union Territory !! Sub-district !! example in WME
! Road type !! Lock level
|-
|-
|  
| {{Freeway}} || 5
*Andhra-Pradesh
*Telangana
|| Mandala || example
|-
|-
|  
| {{Ramp}} || 5
*Arunachal Pradesh
*Assam
|| Circle || example
|-
|-
|  
| {{Major Highway}}|| 4
*Bihar
*Jharkhand
*Meghalaya
*Mizoram
*Tripura
*West Bengal
|| C.D. Block|| example
|-
|-
|  
| {{Minor Highway}} || 3
*Chhattisgarh
*Haryana
*Himachal Pradesh*
*Jammu and Kashmir
*Madhya Pradesh
*Punjab
*Rajasthan*
Uttar Pradesh
*Uttarakhand
|| Tehsil || example
|-
|-
|  
| {{Primary Street}} || 2
*Goa
*Gujarat
*Karnataka
*Kerala*
*Maharashtra
*Tamil Nadu
*Dadra and Nagar Haveli
*Daman and Diu
 
|| Taluka || example
|-
|-
|  
| {{Street}} || Auto (1)
*Manipur
|| Sub-Division || example
|-
|-
|
| {{PLR}} || Auto (1)
*Puducherry
|| Commune Panchayat || Voorbeeld
|-
|-
|
| {{Railroad}} || 2
*Lakshadweep
|| Sub-Division || Voorbeeld
|-
|-
|  
| {{Ferry}} || 5
*Andaman
*Nicobar Islands
*Chandigarh
*Delhi
|| Tehsil || example
 
|}
|}
<small>''Note: The administrative division of India consist of 29 States and 7 Union Territories. These are listed in the State field in WME. Each State or Union Territory is divided into smaller administrative areas, called “Districts”. These in turn are further divided into sub-districts, which have different names across the various States. These sub-districts can be used in the city name to distinguish duplicate streets, or indicate searchable areas.  
[[File:Stubbed road.png|thumbnail|left|A stubbed road]]<br />
''</small>


=Road Segment Locks=
During the mapraid, '''please leave road locks as you find them''', except for Freeways. Freeways may be locked to 5 after:
* All ramps are connected
* Stubs of lower-ranked roads are connected as needed, so that more editors may work on them.


After the mapraid, the roads will be locked to the locking standards for India. You can read [[How_to_classify_and_name_roads_(India)#Road_types|more about road lock standards in India]].  
In areas that still need a lot of work, try to make stubs to the roads: making a short low-level segment for each exit that a low-level editor can attach to.  
{{clear}}
<div style="text-align: right; direction: ltr; margin-left: 1em;">[[#TOC|<small>''
<div style="text-align: right; direction: ltr; margin-left: 1em;">[[#TOC|<small>''
go back to the table of content''</small>]]</div>
go back to the table of content''</small>]]</div>

Revision as of 18:44, 13 September 2016

This part of the wiki page is under construction.


Roads



https://wiki.waze.com/wiki/MMR_India#Adding_Roads https://wiki.waze.com/wiki/MMR_India#Extremely_Narrow_Streets https://wiki.waze.com/wiki/How_to_classify_and_name_roads_(India)

Road Types

  • The main roads in a district or town should at least be set to primary.
  • If segments will be used for through-going traffic or for longer distances connecting districts or towns, they should at least be mH (minor Highway)
  • Main interconnecting roads with fast traffic should ar least be MH (major Highway)

Please read the Quickstart guide to road types before changing the type.

The following convention should be followed where possible, although it is acknowledged that you may need to deviate from it in some circumstances.

Waze Road Type India Road Types (to be checked/updated) Lock Level
 Freeway 
  • National Highways that are referenced in the map below (move map from Road types in Quick Start)
  • Highways appointed by local champs to enable long routes
5
 Major Highway 
  • Other National Highways (exception: inner roads within Indian Metro Cities)
  • Ring Roads around large cities
4
 Minor Highway 
  • All State Highways
  • Arterial Roads, and inner highway roads within Indian Metro Cities
  • Roads used for through-going traffic or for longer distances connecting towns or villages
3
 Primary Street  Busy Roads within Cities, and/or Feeder Roads to Arterial Roads 2
 Street  Residential Roads Automatic (1)
 Parking Lot Road  Used for Petrol Stations, Car Parks Automatic (1)

Always make sure a road is at least connected to a same level of road type or higher. Thus, Waze should be able to route from primary to primary (or higher), from minor to minor (or higher), from major to major (or higher), and from Freeway to Freeway. Another way of explaining this, is that you should be able to continuously drive on the same or higher type of segments for the routing engine to use that road type in the calculations.

This means we need to sometimes make small roads mH, for the possibility of calculating long distance routing. Please discuss with the hosts/mentors if anything is unclear.

Road Naming

The naming of the roads in India is quite a challenge. Many roads don't have a name or are referred to as the "Road from A to B". And if there are specific names, they are often duplicates, even withing one city.

Several aspects are important:

  • searchability
  • visibility/readability in the app
  • continuous routing
  • distinguishing unique addresses

We want Waze to guide us to the correct location. Each location needs to have a unique address. In India, there are 6 or 7 address fields to reach that. We only have 4 fields in WME to define this unique address. Two of them are fixed (Country and State). The other two (Street and City) will be used to define unique addresses. (picture of WME address field with and without added subdivision)

If there are cities with the same name within a State, a street has a name that exist over a very long stretch, or has duplicates within the city, we use the district or the sub-district to make the address unique. See Street naming and City naming for more information.

If you are looking for a proper naming, and you need to add the district or sub-district, look at this page for more information on the administrative division of India.

Street naming

Official streetnames always go in the Primary name field.

  • If a street has two or more names, we choose the shortest as the Primary name, and the other one goes in alternate name.
  • If one or more streets in an area have no names, we can use the district or sub-district in the streetname to distinguish the area (see XX)
  • If there are multiple streets with the same name in the same city, we use the district or sub-district in the city name to distinguish them. (see XX)
  • naming of highways (link to road types?):
    • only when a road has a specific name in urban areas that is used in adresses, it can be in the primary name
    • otherwise, the main road number* will be in primary
all numbers are written as NH-XX, SH-XX, AH-XX and the like
    • all other necessary numbers go in alternate name
    • names indicating destinations go in alternate name (e.g., Mumbai Pune Highway)

Note on highway numbers:

  • we use the numbers as they are on the map
  • we only use the new road numbers if it is requested via UR. We then put the old number as alternate name

City naming

The City field should be used to specify the city, town or village for all the streets within it. Rural roads that are in-between towns should be left without a city name.

Where possible, the simplest unique name should be used.

For very large cities with suburbs, then the suburb should become the name of the town with the city name as the suffix (add example). This is particularly important for generating useful traffic reports, especially when there are long arterial or ring roads that go through several parts of the city.

City Smudges

The editor will display the error message "The highlighted road is too far from the city it was added to" when attempting to add a duplicate name. This is to prevent smudges and means that a different name will need to be chosen for that town or village.

For problems with smudged cities, we are currently gathering several solutions and workarounds.

In case of multiple cities/towns with the same name in one area, we use district or sub-district to distinguish them (see XX).

In short:

  • only in urban areas (urban=where people live in municipalities)
  • use the simplest unique name
  • only when you are absolutely sure of the name
  • otherwise, check the _None_ box

advanced road naming

In case of multiple cities/towns or streetnames with the same name in one area, we use district or sub-district to distinguish them.

to be elaborated

Locking Standard

As the map of India still needs a lot of improvement, we don't want to lock too much that could block starting editors. However, to ensure routing, especially over larger distances, we do use locks for some roads according to the table below. Roads that need more protection because of special situations (construction, complicated design, frequent editing errors) may be locked higher. Make sure to thoroughly check the routing in the live map, before you lock the roads.

If you need to edit a road above your lock level, ask an unlock or ask a higher level editor in one of the communication platforms to do the edit for you.

Road type Lock level
 Freeway  5
 Ramp  5
 Major Highway  4
 Minor Highway  3
 Primary Street  2
 Street  Auto (1)
 Parking Lot Road  Auto (1)
 |-|-|-|-|-|-|-|-|-| Railroad |-|-|-|-|-|-|-|-|-|  2
 • • • • Ferry • • • •   5
A stubbed road



In areas that still need a lot of work, try to make stubs to the roads: making a short low-level segment for each exit that a low-level editor can attach to.