Real time closures: Difference between revisions Discussion View history

(intro rewording - RTC - no routing onto segment)
(→‎Deciding when to use an RTC: rearranging key points)
Line 47: Line 47:
|Permanent
|Permanent
|Kept
|Kept
|Use where a turn onto the segment should be permanently forbidden for all vehicles.
|[[File:Arrow Red-2.png|frameless|left]]Use where a turn onto the segment should be permanently forbidden for all vehicles.
|-
|-
|Conversion to a penalized [[road types|road type]]
|Conversion to a penalized [[road types|road type]]
Line 72: Line 72:


[[File:Closure arrow in WME.png|right]]Real time closures are the preferred way of temporarily controlling traffic for a number of reasons  
[[File:Closure arrow in WME.png|right]]Real time closures are the preferred way of temporarily controlling traffic for a number of reasons  
* They begin to affect routing immediately, within a few minutes of being saved.
* They begin to affect routing within a few minutes of being saved, without waiting for a [[tile update]].
* When the RTC is removed, proper routing can be restored immediately, without waiting for a [[tile update]].
* They allow editors to temporarily prevent routing over specific segments, without having to make any changes to, or damage those segments, and their road types, junctions, or turn restrictions.
* They allow editors to temporarily prevent routing over specific segments, without having to make any changes to, or damage those segments, and their road types, junctions, or turn restrictions.
* They preserve traffic data.
* They preserve traffic data.
* When the RTC is removed, proper routing can be restored immediately, without waiting for a [[tile update]].
* By default (see below), a road closed with an RTC will be continually evaluated for through traffic. If enough traffic is detected driving through a closure, the closure is temporarily deactivated until the traffic is no longer detected. Therefore if an RTC is mistakenly placed on an open segment it will only affect drivers for a few minutes until the through traffic is detected, and the closure deactivated automatically.
* By default (see below), a road closed with an RTC will be continually evaluated for through traffic. If enough traffic is detected driving through a closure, the closure is temporarily deactivated until the traffic is no longer detected. Therefore if an RTC is mistakenly placed on an open segment it will only affect drivers for a few minutes until the through traffic is detected, and the closure deactivated automatically.
* Real time closures are visible in Live Map and the Waze app with special alert icons and segment highlighting. They are also visible in WME with special icons.
* Real time closures are visible in Live Map and the Waze app with special alert icons and segment highlighting. They are also visible in WME with special icons.
* They can be created and commented on within the Waze app, with app creations and comments generating [[Waze Closures Bot|notifications for editors]].
* They can be created and commented on within the Waze app, with app creations and comments generating [[Waze Closures Bot|notifications for editors]].
* They can be associated with [https://www.waze.com/events Major Traffic Events] and can cause notifications to be sent to nearby Wazers.
* They can be associated with [https://www.waze.com/events Major Traffic Events] to get notifications sent to nearby Wazers.
* They eliminate the need for addition and removal of partial restrictions. In fact, ''partial restrictions should not be used redundantly with real time closures'''''.'''
* They eliminate the need for addition and removal of partial restrictions. In fact, ''partial restrictions should not be used redundantly with real time closures''


==How real time closures are added to the map==
==How real time closures are added to the map==

Revision as of 23:23, 8 May 2018

A Real Time Closure (RTC) may be used when a segment is completely closed temporarily in one or both directions to all wazers. When the RTC is active, the affected segment will be marked with red-and-white candy stripes and Waze will not route any traffic through or onto the segment. Only use an RTC when a road is completely closed in one or both directions. Do not use an RTC for lane closures, width restrictions or other cases where traffic is still allowed to move.

The real time closure is the preferred method for temporarily closing roads because it is visible to Wazers and because it helps protect the map.

Deciding when to use an RTC

There are several possible ways to completely prevent Waze from routing traffic over a segment. The best choice depends on the situation.

Method Vehicles Affected Takes Effect Ends Traffic Data Guidance
Real time closure All Immediate Expires Kept Preferred option for temporary (even long term) one-way or two-way closure. Visible to drivers. Immediate effect. Automatically removed when it expires.
Road direction change All Tile update Permanent Kept Use only for permanent change in direction from two-way to one-way.
Time-based segment restriction Some Tile update Optionally expires Kept Use only where the restrictions (time of day/ day of week) are permanent, or where certain vehicle types are allowed or prohibited. Example: No passenger cars on weekdays.
Time-based turn restriction Some Tile update Optionally expires Kept Use where travel on the segment is allowed, but turns onto the segment are temporarily forbidden or else permanently forbidden at certain times of day, days of week or for certain vehicle types. Example: No left turn 4:00pm-6:00pm
Permanent turn restriction All Tile update Permanent Kept
Use where a turn onto the segment should be permanently forbidden for all vehicles.
Conversion to a penalized road type All Tile update Permanent Kept Penalties make routing less likely, but are not absolute. Vehicles with a destination on the segment will be routed onto the segment. Normally  Private Road  is used.
Disconnection All Tile update Permanent Lost Use only if the disconnection is permanent. All turn data is lost.
Deletion All Tile update Permanent Lost Use only if the road is permanently closed. All data is lost.

Real time closures are the preferred way of temporarily controlling traffic for a number of reasons

  • They begin to affect routing within a few minutes of being saved, without waiting for a tile update.
  • When the RTC is removed, proper routing can be restored immediately, without waiting for a tile update.
  • They allow editors to temporarily prevent routing over specific segments, without having to make any changes to, or damage those segments, and their road types, junctions, or turn restrictions.
  • They preserve traffic data.
  • By default (see below), a road closed with an RTC will be continually evaluated for through traffic. If enough traffic is detected driving through a closure, the closure is temporarily deactivated until the traffic is no longer detected. Therefore if an RTC is mistakenly placed on an open segment it will only affect drivers for a few minutes until the through traffic is detected, and the closure deactivated automatically.
  • Real time closures are visible in Live Map and the Waze app with special alert icons and segment highlighting. They are also visible in WME with special icons.
  • They can be created and commented on within the Waze app, with app creations and comments generating notifications for editors.
  • They can be associated with Major Traffic Events to get notifications sent to nearby Wazers.
  • They eliminate the need for addition and removal of partial restrictions. In fact, partial restrictions should not be used redundantly with real time closures

How real time closures are added to the map

Real time closures in WME

Effect on routing

Waze will not choose a closed segment as the closest segment to the destination.

When a real time closure is active, Waze will not route through or even partway through the closed segment in the direction(s) it is closed. It will not route to a destination on the closed segment(s), even if that is the closest segment to the destination. Instead, it will pick a stop point on the next closest segment. If the closed segment is much longer than the part of the road that is actually closed to all traffic, this can result in wazers being sent to a nearby street even though they should be able to drive to the destination. For this reason, if a closure is very localized and going to go on for over a week (as for a bridge replacement) it might be worth the effort to edit the closed segment.

If the Wazer is currently located on a closed segment, waze will find a route that begins in the closed segment and find the shortest distance to a segment with no closure.

How to add a real time closure

  1. Save all pending edits. You will not be able to add or edit closures if there are pending edits. Note that saving an edit which changes the segment number will prevent adding the RTC.
  2. Select the segments you want to close.
  3. Click the Closure tab in the left panel.
  4. Click to + Add Closure and fill out the fields shown:
Description - This section will be viewable in both the client app and the Live Map. Write a description of closure / event here.
Direction - If a single one-way segment is selected, then the correct direction will be autoselected. If the segment is two way and the closure is in only one of the directions, choose that direction here. If multiple directions are selected, then the editor should choose two way for the closure then all two way segments will be closed two ways and the one ways will be closed in the appropriate direction.
Event - If this closure is part of a Major Traffic Event, choose it from the drop-down list. If not present then add the Event.
Start/End Date & Time - Enter date/time the closure will remain active (the start date can be a date in the past). Enter the correct time for the closure for the local time zone of the segment being closed, regardless of where you are located while entering the closures. Time is entered in 24-hour format and date uses the YYYY-MM-DD. The first minute of the day begins at 00:00 and the last minute of the day begins at 23:59.
  • End date can not be more than 183 days after the start date and no more than one year after the current date.
  • Real-time closures are active for the full minute they are set for (up to 00 seconds of the next minute)
  • Do not use 24:00 as a start or end time.
  • 00:00 is the first minute of the day. Avoid using it as end time.
  • 23:59 is the last minute of the day. Avoid using it as a start time.
  • A closure set for Start: 03:00, End: 04:00, will actually be closed for 60 minutes and 59 seconds, from 03:00:00 - 04:00:59.
  • The longest duration closure is 183 days.
  • For a 365-day closure beginning immediately, enter a 183 day closure followed by a 182 day closure.
Save & Check
  • In Live Map, active closures will appear with red closure icons in WME, and with closure alerts bubbles and red and white (candy stripe) road segment highlighting in Live Map immediately.
  • May have to zoom in to see all closures in Live Map.
  • In Event Mode, if the closures are associated with an event, to see candy stripe road segment highlighting in WME
  • Inactive closures do not appear at all in Live Map or the Waze app, and will appear with gray closure icons in WME only.
Cross streets - which segments to close

Closing several segments of a road will prevent Waze from routing wazers down that road. But it will not prevent Waze from routing wazers across the road at the intersections. Often in work zones and for special events (parades, marathons, festivals), cross traffic should not be allowed at some or all of the junctions. If traffic going across your Real-Time Closure must be blocked at a junction, you will need to close at least one of the cross street segments as well. Waze will not route up into a closed segment to reach a destination within it, but it will route out of the "most convenient end" of a closed segment if the user starts within it. So if you need to allow wazers to reach destinations less than a block from the closed road, close the cross street segments in the direction moving away from the closed road.

  • Regular cross-streets
  • Close two-way cross-street segments on both sides of the closed intersection. Each segment should be closed in the direction traveling away from the closed junction. Closing all outbound segments routing from the intersection will prevent routing across the intersection's junction node to reach a destination or leave a starting point, regardless of the user's position in relation to that junction node.
  • If traffic at an intersection is being directed by police, then it is not necessary to apply a closure at the cross street. Waze will detect the traffic slowdown and route accordingly.
  • Close one-way cross-street segments on the side traveling away from the closed junction. Closing the "way out" from the junction prevents Waze routing wazers through the junction.
  • Median segments of closed divided roadways
  • When both directions of a divided roadway are closed and cross traffic is disallowed, consider closing only the median segment. This is enough to prevent cross-traffic routing from either side.

Illustrations and examples

Controlling cross traffic through a closed route link to this section
Click expand on the right side here to see Example scenarios with illustrations.
New Year's Day Parade in RTC Town
RTC Town has scheduled a parade down Main St on January 1 starting at 13:00 and ending at 14:00. Traffic must not be allowed to travel along Main St or cross at any intersection.
Select the parade route on Main St and set a two-way closure between 13:00 and 14:00 on January 1.
Plum Rd is a two-way cross-street, Orchard Rd, and Mulberry St are one-way cross-streets. To route traffic to the correct sides of these streets, the segments north and south of Main St should be set with one-way closures between 13:00 and 14:00 in the direction traveling away from their junction with Main St.
The completed set of closures in this example would look like those on the right. We’re all set to watch the parade!
Divided road closed for construction
Willow St will be closed for two weeks for construction. So we set a closure for the length of both carriageways.
Cherry Ave crosses Willow St in a ‘H’ configuration. In this case, we need to close only the median segment to prevent traffic from being routed through the intersection or to the wrong side of Willow. Note, we set no closures on Rose St because it is a T-intersection.
Slideshow - how to create Real Time Closures link to this section
Click expand on the right side here to see a slideshow developed by waze staff

This slideshow was prepared by Waze staff to show how to add a closure in WME. It contains information on which segments to select as part of a closure as well. The information in this slide show is also presented throughout this page in text.

How we learn about closures

The editing community can be informed about these closures by:

  • URs/MPs submitted through the app
  • Knowledge of local happenings
  • Notification from the local community / Waze Major Traffic Event Team
  • Long-term closures

All Real-Time Closures follow the same general principles below, regardless of which method is used to submit them. Depending on which method is used there are additional guidance and instructions in the corresponding unique subsections below.

Connected Citizens Program

Through the Connected Citizens Program, Waze shares and receives information from select entities which partner with Waze. This information can include Road Closures which are entered in WME directly by Waze Staff or the CCP's employees. Wazers are encouraged to promote these relationships with their local governing entities.



Closure guidance and tips

Usernames and closures

Adding a closure does not put your name as the last editor for the segment (Updated By: user (#)), however your name does appear in the segment's history. You can also see who added an active closure by looking at the alert in Live Map or the client.


Closure feature permissions
  • Usual situation
    • Rank: Your rank must be 3 or above.
    • Edit permission The segment must be in your editing area, and be locked at or below your rank
  • RTC area - a special-purpose area granted by your RC for the purpose of making closures. Generally granted to CCP partners
    • You can apply a closure to any segment within the RTC area, no matter the lock level.

If you are unable to close a segment, then contact an editor who can via PM, in WME Chat, or in Discord. Some regions of the US use a closure form to submit closure requests. Please check with your local community.

Closing recently edited segments

Real-Time Closures entered using this feature are not subject to waiting for a tile update, they will go live almost immediately. But they will only work on segments and its associated nodes that have already been uploaded to the map. If the Segment ID has changed, then you will not be able to save the closure. WME will display the error message (!) Element Segment with ID xxxxxxxx was not found (probably deleted). Wait until after the changes are included in a tile build, and then enter the closure again and it should save fine.

For this reason, if you need to remove a segment or cut a segment in two, first place a Time based segment restriction on the segment, then apply the closure. After the next tile update, the segment restrictions will be in place at least until the next tile update. You can then remove the closure and make the types of changes that will prevent applying the closure. After one more tile update, you should be able to remove Time Based Segment Restrictions (TBSR) and reapply the closure. This should allow you (after 2 or 3 days) to limit a closure to a damaged bridge rather than being forced to apply it to a mile-long segment of road.

Editing segments with closures

NOTE: If a segment is closed using this feature, the segment will not be editable by any editors - regardless of rank - while the closure is in effect. This is by design, to prevent any changes to segment IDs which will corrupt the closure.

If you need to edit the segment, you will have to first remove the Temporary Closure (copy the details first), then modify the segment and save. If the edit did not alter the segment or junction node IDs, you can immediately replace the Temporary Closure with the details you copied to the appropriate segments. If you altered any segment or junction node IDs, you will have to wait until after the next tile update before reentering the Temporary Closure.

Closing multiple segments

Real-Time Closures can be added to multiple segments simultaneously by selecting all the affected segments first. Be careful to verify all the segments after you save that the Real-Time Closures were added properly. It's been reported before when multiple Real-Time Closures were added at once, that some of the segments either weren't closed, or had incorrect details in the closure (e.g. direction).

Segment direction for one-way closures

If only some of the segments are one-way, or some one-way segments are in opposing direction (B-A, A-B), you can set the Closure as two-way for all the segments. When you save you will see an error line for each direction of a closed segment which failed to save because the segment is one-way. You can ignore the error, and all your segments should be closed in all possible directions. (Be sure to double check them all.)

Major Traffic Event (MTE) closure sheets

There are two ways to create Major Traffic Events in Waze.

  1. The easiest way, for editors of rank 3 and higher, is to create the event and the closures in the Waze Map Editor.
  2. The other way is to use the Events page to request an MTE closure sheet. Once the sheet is filled out with information in WME, Waze Closure staff members will upload the closures and (optionally) get a message out to wazers in the area.

More on closure sheets


These Closure Sheets have some unique advantages over submitting closures directly in WME, and also have some unique guidelines listed below. They still also follow all the general guidance for Real-Time Closures listed above.

  • Real-Time Closures which could just as easily be submitted using the Closure feature in WME, shouldn't be submitted using the sheets.
  • Check your email; find out who will be working with you on these closures, when they are available to upload closures. Make sure you have time to double-check closures before the event begins.
  • Check the sheet for required fields (closure start and end time, permalink, road name, your username, etc). guidelines are similar to guidelines for closures entered using WME
  • Once each row of the sheet has been uploaded, it will be marked as such. If any rows are not uploaded, check the sheet comments and check your email.
  • Closures will go live as soon as they are uploaded
  • It may be possible to upload a closure involving a segment ID, node ID, or node location that have moved since the last tile update; The real time closure will not become active until these segment and node changes go live.

Report closure feature in the Waze app

Users in the mobile app can mark a closed road they see while driving. Instructions on how to use this feature in the Waze app is available in the Waze Help Center.

  • This feature is typically used for unexpected, short-term closures of up to a few days.
  • This closure will immediately show up in the reporting user's app.
  • Generally, the closure will not show up for anyone else until several other users have reported the same closure.
  • Editors can become "trusted" to report closures and fewer additional reports will be required to make their in-app closures go live.
  • If the editor is rank 5 or higher, the in-app closure will go into effect immediately.

App reported closures in WME

In-app closures are also visible from within WME

  • The start date will be 1969 or 1970
  • These closures can be deleted or edited by any rank 3+ editor
  • If there are multiple app-reported RTCs on a segment, an error will be generated when trying to edit and save changes to one of them. Remove duplicate entries first, and then make changes to the one remaining entry.