Wayfinder: Difference between revisions Discussion View history

(added content from JSG/Interchanges)
 
(changed guidance and formatting for TIO stuff)
Line 1: Line 1:
=== Wayfinders ===
A '''wayfinder''' is a junction that instructs users on a certain road how to continue on that same road, in situations where it may be beneficial to have such an instruction, and there would otherwise be no instruction. Wayfinders often use short segments (known as wayfinder segments) to specify instructions, and sometimes they use [[turn instruction override]]s as well. This page will explain the different use cases of wayfinders to give keep, exit or continue instructions.


A '''wayfinder''' gives a user an instruction directing them how to continue on the road the user is already on, in situations where it may be unclear, and there would otherwise be no instruction.


 
== Terminology ==
==== Terminology ====


A '''travel lane''' is a lane which is long enough that a naïve driver might consider it a long-distance lane. For our purposes we will clarify this as any lane which;
A '''travel lane''' is a lane which is long enough that a naïve driver might consider it a long-distance lane. For our purposes we will clarify this as any lane which;
Line 10: Line 8:
#has not just started within a mile before the exit.
#has not just started within a mile before the exit.


The '''typical side''' for an exit depends on the traffic side for that country. In a country with [[Right-hand traffic]] i.e. the USA, the typical side for an exit is the right side.
A '''continuation path''' or '''continuation''' is the group of lanes after the junction which continue to be the same road as they were before the junction. (In the following example, the lanes which continue to be I-47)
 
The '''atypical side''' for an exit is the opposite of the typical side described above.
 
A '''continuation path''' or '''continuation''' is the group of lanes after the fork which continue to be the same road as it was before the fork. (In the following example, the lanes which continue to be I-47)


[[File:Lane definitions.png|400px|thumbnail|center]]
[[File:Lane definitions.png|400px|thumbnail|center]]
{{clear}}
{{clear}}


==== Criteria ====
== Keep instruction ==
 
=== Criteria ===
A wayfinder is warranted in the following cases:
A wayfinder to give a "keep" instruction on a continuation is warranted in the following cases:
*The continuation path on a controlled-access highway or freeway, when an exit is present on the typical side, has at least two fewer ''travel lanes'' after the exit than before it;
*The continuation path on a controlled-access highway or freeway, when an exit is present on the right side, has at least two fewer ''travel lanes'' after the exit than before it;
*The continuation path on a controlled-access highway or freeway has the same number of lanes as, or fewer lanes than, the exit path after the fork;
*The continuation path on a controlled-access highway or freeway has the same number of lanes as, or fewer lanes than, the exit path after the fork;
*The continuation path on an uncontrolled highway, or when an exit is present on the atypical side of a controlled-access highway or freeway, has at least one fewer ''travel lane'' after the exit than before it;
*The continuation path on an uncontrolled highway, or when an exit is present on the left side of a controlled-access highway or freeway, has at least one fewer ''travel lane'' after the exit than before it;
*The continuation path consists of a single lane; or
*The continuation path consists of a single lane; or
*Other conditions exist that may suggest a fork, rather than an exit (use your better judgement, and discretion) -- for example:
*Other conditions exist that may suggest a fork, rather than an exit (use your better judgement, and discretion) -- for example:
Line 39: Line 33:


==== Configuration ====
==== Configuration ====
These configurations have been designed based on a very in-depth understanding of [[How_Waze_determines_turn_/_keep_/_exit_maneuvers|Waze's standard rules for generating instructions]]. Please don't deviate from these precise configurations.


* Each "stub" segment should be {{:Segment length/Minimum}} long. This is long enough so it will not cause routing problems, but it is short enough to suppress display of the names (on Freeway stubs) and keep freeways looking contiguous (on Ramp stubs).
* Each "stub" segment should be {{:Segment length/Minimum}} long. This is long enough so it will not cause routing problems, but it is short enough to suppress display of the names (on Freeway stubs) and keep freeways looking contiguous (on Ramp stubs).
* The OUT segments should have a ''turn angle'' of 10°-20° off of the mid-line on opposite sides of each other, consistent with [[Junction_Style_Guide/Interchanges#Freeway_split_geometry|the geometry for freeway forks]]. This will allow for easy identification in WME, but still look seamless in the client app.
* The OUT segments should have a ''turn angle'' of 10°-15° off of the mid-line on opposite sides of each other, consistent with [[Junction_Style_Guide/Interchanges#Freeway_split_geometry|the geometry for freeway forks]]. This will allow for easy identification in WME, but still look seamless in the client app.




Line 64: Line 56:
|-
|-
| Right
| Right
| Basic exit
| Exit
| '''Continuation side'''<br/>{{Ramp|Named Ramp stub}} → {{Freeway|Named Fwy}}
| '''Continuation side'''<br/>{{Ramp|Named Ramp stub}} → {{Freeway|Named Fwy}}
| '''Exit side'''<br/>{{Ramp|Named Ramp}}
| '''Exit side'''<br/>{{Ramp|Named Ramp}}
Line 76: Line 68:
|-
|-
| Left
| Left
| Basic exit
| Exit
| '''Exit side'''<br/>{{Freeway|Unnamed Fwy stub}} → {{Ramp|Named Ramp}}
| '''Exit side'''<br/>{{Freeway|Unnamed Fwy stub}} → {{Ramp|Named Ramp}}
| '''Continuation side'''<br/>{{Freeway|Named Fwy stub}} → {{Freeway|Named Fwy}}
| '''Continuation side'''<br/>{{Freeway|Named Fwy stub}} → {{Freeway|Named Fwy}}
Line 91: Line 83:
==== Segment naming ====
==== Segment naming ====
Keep these basic principles in mind:
Keep these basic principles in mind:
* The OUT segments must both be the same type (either {{Freeway}}, {{Major Highway}}, {{Minor Highway}}, or {{Ramp}}, as explained below).
* If turn instruction overrides are not used, the OUT segments must both be the same type (either {{Freeway}}, {{Major Highway}}, {{Minor Highway}}, or {{Ramp}}, as explained below).
* Each OUT segment must have a name different than the IN segment.
* If turn instruction overrides are not used, each OUT segment must have a name different than the IN segment.
** '''NOTE:''' An unnamed segment (no-name box checked) is considered to have a blank name, and not the inherited name for these purposes. Therefore either both OUTs must be no-name, or both must have their own unique name.
* OUT segments should be named with the information displayed on the roadway signs.
* OUT segments should be named with the information displayed on the roadway signs.
** However, if this would leave an OUT segment with the same name as the IN segment, the OUT segment should be left unnamed (i.e., check the "no name" box).
** However, if this would leave an OUT segment with the same name as the IN segment, use a turn instruction override instead and don't use a short segment for the continuation.
 
{{mbox|type=important|text=Previously in these situations segment naming was modified in one of the following ways {{u|''in order of preference''}}:
#Add a control/destination city, if it is known, to the OUT segment name.
#Remove the compass cardinal from the OUT segment name.
#Add a space to the end of the OUT segment name (note that this will be flagged by the [[Community_Plugins,_Extensions_and_Tools#WME_Validator|WME Validator script]], if active, and possibly result in undoing by another editor)
#Create a stub in the IN segment just before the junction with no street name.
#*'''NOTE:''' This option should only be used as a last resort because it prevents the [[Routing_server|routing server]] from properly calculating [[Turn delays|turn delays]], and may result in inefficient routing through the area.
 
If you see any of these set-ups, please correct it to one of the two proper methods listed above.}}


If the continuation is '''signed''', and a wayfinder is warranted,
If the continuation is '''signed''', and a wayfinder is warranted,
Line 110: Line 92:
**If the name of the continuation is included but is not listed first on the sign, move the name of the continuing road to the beginning of the segment name.  (e.g. In this wayfinder the highway you are on now, and continuing on is I-275, so the segment name should be "I-275 N / I-74 E / US-52 E / Cincinnati".)
**If the name of the continuation is included but is not listed first on the sign, move the name of the continuing road to the beginning of the segment name.  (e.g. In this wayfinder the highway you are on now, and continuing on is I-275, so the segment name should be "I-275 N / I-74 E / US-52 E / Cincinnati".)
* If the continuation sign '''does not contain''' the name or shield of the continuing road, then the road name should begin with "to".
* If the continuation sign '''does not contain''' the name or shield of the continuing road, then the road name should begin with "to".


If the word "TO" is explicitly included on the continuation sign,
If the word "TO" is explicitly included on the continuation sign,
Line 118: Line 99:
** If any included control cities or road names correlate to the roads '''not''' affected by the "TO", then those control cities or road names should remain in place before "/ to [road(s)]".
** If any included control cities or road names correlate to the roads '''not''' affected by the "TO", then those control cities or road names should remain in place before "/ to [road(s)]".
*** If Morristown is served by I-80, the continuation segment should be named '''"I-80 / Morristown / to I-280"'''.{{clear}}
*** If Morristown is served by I-80, the continuation segment should be named '''"I-80 / Morristown / to I-280"'''.{{clear}}


If the continuation is '''not signed''', and a wayfinder is warranted,
If the continuation is '''not signed''', and a wayfinder is warranted,
* If the OUT segment is a continuation of the same road, it should be left unnamed (check the "no name" box).
* If the OUT segment is a continuation of the same road, use a "keep" turn instruction override, and do not use a short segment.
* If the OUT segment is an exit, it should be named following the guidelines for an unsigned exit.
* If the OUT segment is an exit, it should be named following the guidelines for an unsigned exit.
* If the OUT segment is a short continuation of the same road leading to another road, name the segment starting with "to" followed by the name of the road to which the continuation leads, following these guidelines:
* If the OUT segment is a short continuation of the same road leading to another road, name the segment starting with "to" followed by the name of the road to which the continuation leads, following these guidelines:
** {{anchor|no BGS to}}[[File:No BGS To exit.PNG|300px|thumbnail|right]]Where the wayfinder is just before, but not at, the termination of a road, so the continuation OUT segment is named for the road that the continuation leads to at the termination. However you still must travel for a short distance on the continuation of this road until those exits/termination. [[File:No BGS To exit zoom out.PNG|300px|thumbnail|right]]Our example here is a wayfinder on US-1-9 N (Truck), the left OUT is the continuation, however the right OUT also continues on the same road until it intersects with SR-440, with an exit to SR-440 S along this short segment. There are no roadway signs for any of these forks, or exits/terminations. The OUT segment here would be named '''"to SR-440 S / Communipaw Ave"''', and the SR-440 exit will be named following the [[Road_names#Exit_ramps_and_entrance_ramps_.28on-ramps.29|unsigned exit guidelines]]. However it may be appropriate (if there are no House Numbers, or other on ramps past this wayfinder before it reaches the exit, to leave this entire portion with no name, and the instruction will inherit the name of the next road to which you are going.{{clear}}
** {{anchor|no BGS to}}[[File:No BGS To exit.PNG|300px|thumbnail|right]]Where the wayfinder is just before, but not at, the termination of a road, so the continuation OUT segment is named for the road that the continuation leads to at the termination. However you still must travel for a short distance on the continuation of this road until those exits/termination. [[File:No BGS To exit zoom out.PNG|300px|thumbnail|right]]Our example here is a wayfinder on US-1-9 N (Truck), the left OUT is the continuation, however the right OUT also continues on the same road until it intersects with SR-440, with an exit to SR-440 S along this short segment. There are no roadway signs for any of these forks, or exits/terminations. The OUT segment here would be named '''"to SR-440 S / Communipaw Ave"''', and the SR-440 exit will be named following the [[Road_names#Exit_ramps_and_entrance_ramps_.28on-ramps.29|unsigned exit guidelines]]. However it may be appropriate (if there are no House Numbers, or other on ramps past this wayfinder before it reaches the exit, to leave this entire portion with no name, and the instruction will inherit the name of the next road to which you are going.{{clear}}


== Continue instruction ==
=== Criteria ===


Wayfinder naming examples
== Wayfinder naming examples ==
<div style="font-size:smaller">
<div style="font-size:smaller">
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align:center"
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align:center"

Revision as of 12:17, 11 July 2017

A wayfinder is a junction that instructs users on a certain road how to continue on that same road, in situations where it may be beneficial to have such an instruction, and there would otherwise be no instruction. Wayfinders often use short segments (known as wayfinder segments) to specify instructions, and sometimes they use turn instruction overrides as well. This page will explain the different use cases of wayfinders to give keep, exit or continue instructions.


Terminology

A travel lane is a lane which is long enough that a naïve driver might consider it a long-distance lane. For our purposes we will clarify this as any lane which;

  1. before nearing the exit, is neither striped nor signed as a departing lane over a significant length (approximately ¾ a mile, or its full length, whichever is shorter), and
  2. has not just started within a mile before the exit.

A continuation path or continuation is the group of lanes after the junction which continue to be the same road as they were before the junction. (In the following example, the lanes which continue to be I-47)

Keep instruction

Criteria

A wayfinder to give a "keep" instruction on a continuation is warranted in the following cases:

  • The continuation path on a controlled-access highway or freeway, when an exit is present on the right side, has at least two fewer travel lanes after the exit than before it;
  • The continuation path on a controlled-access highway or freeway has the same number of lanes as, or fewer lanes than, the exit path after the fork;
  • The continuation path on an uncontrolled highway, or when an exit is present on the left side of a controlled-access highway or freeway, has at least one fewer travel lane after the exit than before it;
  • The continuation path consists of a single lane; or
  • Other conditions exist that may suggest a fork, rather than an exit (use your better judgement, and discretion) -- for example:
    • The physical roadway itself forks or diverges with no clear straight-ahead direction;
    • The road which appears to be straight ahead is not the actual continuation;
    • Signage and striping do not clearly provide all expected "exit" indications, or do so inconsistently; or
    • Signs are present with arrows pointing left and right but no sign clearly establishes the continuation.


Need sample images for "lane drops" and "non-obvious continuations"; also, example of BGS with lane arrows

In these cases, we need to use a wayfinder configuration. Each wayfinder configuration will have one "IN" segment and two "OUT" segments.

Configuration

  • Each "stub" segment should be 19.69 ft (6 m) long. This is long enough so it will not cause routing problems, but it is short enough to suppress display of the names (on Freeway stubs) and keep freeways looking contiguous (on Ramp stubs).
  • The OUT segments should have a turn angle of 10°-15° off of the mid-line on opposite sides of each other, consistent with the geometry for freeway forks. This will allow for easy identification in WME, but still look seamless in the client app.


To configure the wayfinder,

  • If the numbered/signed exit is on the right, the OUT segments should be  Ramp  type. This will give an "exit right" instruction for the exit and a "stay to the left" instruction for the continuation.
    • For a basic exit, use a named Ramp stub for the continuation, and a standard Ramp for the exit.
    • For a freeway fork, use a Ramp stub on both sides.
  • If the numbered/signed exit is on the left, the OUT segments type should be the same as  the IN segment , in the following examples we will use the  Freeway  type. This will give "stay to the" instructions on both sides (if  Ramp  segments were used, Waze would give a confusing "exit right" instruction for the continuation).
    • For a basic exit, use a named Freeway stub for the continuation, and an unnamed Freeway stub followed by a named Ramp for the exit.
    • For a freeway fork, use named Freeway stubs on both sides.
Exit direction Type Left OUT configuration Right OUT configuration Example
Right Exit Continuation side
 Named Ramp stub  Named Fwy 
Exit side
 Named Ramp 
Right Fwy fork Continuation side
 Named Ramp stub  Named Fwy 
Exit side
 Named Ramp stub  Named Fwy 
Left Exit Exit side
 Unnamed Fwy stub  Named Ramp 
Continuation side
 Named Fwy stub  Named Fwy 
Left Fwy fork Exit side
 Named Fwy stub  Named Fwy 
Continuation side
 Named Fwy stub  Named Fwy 

Segment naming

Keep these basic principles in mind:

  • If turn instruction overrides are not used, the OUT segments must both be the same type (either  Freeway ,  Major Highway ,  Minor Highway , or  Ramp , as explained below).
  • If turn instruction overrides are not used, each OUT segment must have a name different than the IN segment.
  • OUT segments should be named with the information displayed on the roadway signs.
    • However, if this would leave an OUT segment with the same name as the IN segment, use a turn instruction override instead and don't use a short segment for the continuation.

If the continuation is signed, and a wayfinder is warranted,

  • If the continuation sign contains the name or shield of the continuing road, do not use "to" at the beginning of the name of the OUT segment. e.g., a freeway fork where one side is the continuation of the same freeway (the user is already on the road, not going "to" it). Most wayfinders will fit this criterion.
    • If the name of the continuation is included but is not listed first on the sign, move the name of the continuing road to the beginning of the segment name. (e.g. In this wayfinder the highway you are on now, and continuing on is I-275, so the segment name should be "I-275 N / I-74 E / US-52 E / Cincinnati".)
  • If the continuation sign does not contain the name or shield of the continuing road, then the road name should begin with "to".

If the word "TO" is explicitly included on the continuation sign,

  • Move the shields or names affected by the "TO" to the end of the segment name after a slash (/). (The example BGS shown is for the continuation of I-80, which leads to I-280, with a control city Morristown.)
    • If any included control cities or road names correlate only to the roads affected by the "TO", then those control cities or road names should be moved after the "/ to [road(s)] /" on the segment name.
      • If Morristown is served by I-280 and not by I-80, the continuation segment should be "I-80 / to I-280 / Morristown".
    • If any included control cities or road names correlate to the roads not affected by the "TO", then those control cities or road names should remain in place before "/ to [road(s)]".
      • If Morristown is served by I-80, the continuation segment should be named "I-80 / Morristown / to I-280".

If the continuation is not signed, and a wayfinder is warranted,

  • If the OUT segment is a continuation of the same road, use a "keep" turn instruction override, and do not use a short segment.
  • If the OUT segment is an exit, it should be named following the guidelines for an unsigned exit.
  • If the OUT segment is a short continuation of the same road leading to another road, name the segment starting with "to" followed by the name of the road to which the continuation leads, following these guidelines:
    • Where the wayfinder is just before, but not at, the termination of a road, so the continuation OUT segment is named for the road that the continuation leads to at the termination. However you still must travel for a short distance on the continuation of this road until those exits/termination.
      Our example here is a wayfinder on US-1-9 N (Truck), the left OUT is the continuation, however the right OUT also continues on the same road until it intersects with SR-440, with an exit to SR-440 S along this short segment. There are no roadway signs for any of these forks, or exits/terminations. The OUT segment here would be named "to SR-440 S / Communipaw Ave", and the SR-440 exit will be named following the unsigned exit guidelines. However it may be appropriate (if there are no House Numbers, or other on ramps past this wayfinder before it reaches the exit, to leave this entire portion with no name, and the instruction will inherit the name of the next road to which you are going.

Continue instruction

Criteria

Wayfinder naming examples

# Continuation sign Continuing road name Rule Waze road name
context image
1 I-10 E / New Orleans Business District I-10 E Matches - do not use "to" I-10 E / New Orleans Business District
# Continuation sign Continuing road name Rule Waze road name
2 I-71 N / Columbus I-471 N Does not match – use "to" to I-71 N / Columbus
# Continuation sign Continuing road name Rule Waze road name
3 I-74 E / US-52 E / I-275 N / Cincinnati I-275 N Included but not first – move to beginning I-275 N / I-74 E / US-52 E / Cincinnati
# Continuation sign Continuing road name Rule Waze road name
BGS image WME image context image
4 name
# Continuation sign Continuing road name Rule Waze road name
image image image
5 name